In early January 2011, the ol’ editor, Mr. Pyne, and I were sitting in a local restaurant having a coffee break with Gene Jontry, a history buff when it comes to the subject of the annual McLean Couinty/Heart Of Illinois Tournament.
At that meeting, Jontry, who had done a little of everything at various points in his life as far as the Tournament was concerned – player, coach, school administrator, and Tournament organizing committee member – was helping us with a series of articles we were preparing in time for the 100th edition of the Tournament.
As a result, he had plenty of stats, data, trivia, and informational tidbits to help us prepare articles. His collection of information also included rosters from many teams that had played in the tournament over the years. One of those rosters provided absolute proof – both statistical and photographic – that, yes, indeed, Mr. Pyne did play on the Lexington Minutemen varsity team his senior year in 1964.
But, so, too, did guys like Jim Dady, Fred Hardman, Dennis Garrett, Gary Yeagle, and Ed Brucker – all molded into manhood through sports, as athletes usually are, in this case by their head coach, E. W. “Duke†Towner.
When Jontry completed his history lesson, I mentally filed the Lexington details away in my brain for future reference and hoped for an opportunity to use them later down the road. With the Illinois High School Association (IHSA) State Basketball Tournaments upon us, beginning with the Girls’ Class 1A-2A Tourney this weekend at Redbird Arena, this seemed the ideal time to let the players of the previous era give us an opportunity to help them – and those of us who were not here then – remember when.
Towner’s troops finished the 1963-64 season 24-3 which included winning the 53rd McLean County Tournament that year by beating Octavia, 47-36, at what was at the time a reasonably brand new facility – Horton Field House on the Illinois State University campus. With 7,000 seats, compared to the Tourney’s previous home at that time – McCormick Hall Gym on ISU’s campus – it must have seemed palatial. Dady, Hardman, Brucker, Pyne, and Mark Young were Towner’s starting five that season.
Two of the Minutemen’s three losses came as bookends that season, by Octavia’s Rockets team, although Towner’s Minutemen did get a measure of revenge beating the Rockets in the County Tourney title game, 47-36. “In those days, Octavia was pretty dominant in the area,†explained Gary Yeagle, who was playing guard that season, and now is retired from his job as an attorney for State Farm Insurance.
Yeagle said he has no problem ranking Lexington’s 1964 team right behind their brethren from the 1974 Minutemen squad that went to State in Basketball. “We probably could have held our own against the ’74 team,†Yeagle joked.
For Dennis Garrett, he remembers the last minute of the County Championship for a basket he made. “We were down to the final minute, and we were just trying to protect the lead, and I just happened to get an open shot from around 10 or 12 feet,†Garrett recalled. “I just went ahead and took it, and luckily, made it.â€
But it wasn’t done without consequence. Garrett, at that time a senior forward, said that’s because he “got severely chewed out†by Towner for taking the shot, in spite of getting points from it. Garrett admits the Minutemen coach at that point in the game was “just wanting the players to hold onto the ball and let the time run out.â€
Jim Dady said the championship victory in the County Tournament over Octavia has never exited his mind. “It was one of the highlights of that season,†said Dady, who retired from banking. “One of the takeaways of my high school playing career was to say I played in the last County Tournament played in McCormick and the first County tournament played at Horton Field House.â€
Dady said Lexington entered the County title game with a 7-2 mark. “Entering that game was a big deal for us because Octavia had beaten Lexington seven straight times before that County Championship game. Because of that, we really wanted to beat those guys, and we played pretty well,†Dady said. The County Championship for the Minutemen turned out to be a first loss of that season for the Rockets.
When the 1963-64 season began winding down and Regional play began at Fairbury, the large number of schools that vied for the title included larger Twin City schools like Normal Community High and Bloomington High; ISU’s Lab School, University High; as well as the smaller schools like Lexington and Octavia. In that Regional, the Minutemen faced U-High, and Octavia squared off against the Ironmen.
By the time those playoffs arrived, Lexington found itself facing U-High, who were coached by Bob Metcalf. Now 87, Metcalf said when IHSA overseers did the seeding for the Regionals, they opted for something Metcalf believes should not have happened. And yet, it did, but certainly wouldn’t today. IHSA representatives chose the seedings for the teams at the Regional by drawing numbers out of a hat for each team, Metcalf explained.
“Going into the Regional, the teams were seeded 1 through 6,†Metcalf began. “Lexington and U-High played each other in the Regional’s first game. But, those two teams had the best records, so they really should have played in the Regional’s last game.â€
“For some unknown reason, IHSA used a blind draw,†Metcalf said. “We beat Lexington. They were out and done for the season.†U-High, under Metcalf, would get as far as the Super-Sectional where they would lose to Gibson City.
“Winning the championship of the Regional was quite pleasing, getting that little bit of payback or revenge on Lexington, who had beaten us just the month before in the County Tournament,†said Dennis Kagel, now owner of Dennis Kagel Financial Services in Normal. As the 1963-64 season was winding down, Kagel was a junior at Octavia. But the Rockets’ turn for celebration turned out to be short-lived as they were beaten in the next round by Stephen Decatur High School, ironically in a quarterfinal game played at Horton Field House.
These kids-now-mostly retirees hold many a memory about playing some of the first games at Horton Field House in the McLean County Tournament. Not to mention playing in State playoff there, too. A word I heard a lot during interviews was “big.†After all, these kids played in what were, by today’s standards, small gyms.
“It was a big deal to play at Horton Field House, and to win at the County Tournament there was a really big deal,†Gary Yeagle said. “It was really special.â€
Playing at Horton was “pretty much a culture shock walking in there,†Dennis Garrett said. “Especially when you walk out on that floor for the first time when you’ve been used to playing in a gym that holds 500 people, if you’re lucky. It was definitely a different world. McCormick Gym was bigger, but it was similar to a high school gym.â€
“People came and basically stayed for the game you were playing in, and the gym for that game was full,†Garrett added. Garrett calls winning the County title at Horton his most memorable personal basketball memory. Today, he said, the current home of the present-day McLean County/Heart Of Illinois Conference Tournament, Illinois Wesleyan University’s Shirk Center, “feels more like Horton.â€
“When we stepped on the court at Horton for the County Tournament, we’d never seen anything that big,†Jim Dady added. He recalled the Lexington-Octavia championship showdown drawing roughly 3,000 fans. “We’d never played before crowds larger than 300 at McCormick.â€
“Playing at Horton was really a special thing because, not only was the County Tournament a big deal in those days, but I would guess, at that time, there were 14 or 15 schools involved,†said Dennis Kagel. “It was a week-long extravaganza for basketball fans.â€
The current extravaganza now involves girls and boys teams, lasts four weeks, covering four classes of teams, taking about a month and a half to complete. One does not stop to think in those terms during the playoffs. We just look at the seasons, mostly the way coaches teach their players to – one game at a time. Well, starting Friday, that game-at-a-time process starts to wind down toward crowning State champions. And we will all be watching. And cheering for, rooting for, and hoping for a positive outcome for our favorite teams. Is it any wonder it is referred to as madness? It may not have been called that when these men played, but the feeling certainly sounds the same.